Mushroom coffee is a smarter way to fuel your day than the traditional brew people have settled for all these years. You get much smoother energy, real cognitive enhancement, and a host of other benefits - without the jitters or crash!
But with so many great brands on the market it can be hard to narrow it down to the best formulation for your specific ritual. We see Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Laird Superfoods compared all the time, and we’re here to help you weigh your options and pick the right one.
Each blend brings something special to your daily routine, and there’s a bit of overlap in ingredients: Lion’s Mane, Chaga, and Cordyceps are found in all three. But that’s where the similarities end. We’ll compare ingredients, potential benefits, taste, value, and more.
Just want the quick answer about which is best between Laird Superfood vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom? Look no further than our nootropic coffee. You get more mushrooms and nootropics per serving than the other two brands (and other brands, for that matter) by a long shot.
The best part? You’ll actually look forward to starting the day or powering through afternoon slumps with Noom. It tastes great and mixes easily, all while supporting peak cognitive performance, smooth energy, immune function, stress response, and gut health.
Feel the difference with Noom!
“Tastes much better but the big thing is the higher amount of essential ingredients that give me the mental boost I was looking for.” - Anthony
“I've been drinking mushroom coffee for almost a year now. I've had great success with them, having tried several brands. Noom has got to be the best by far! One dose goes much farther than the others, plus I love the chocolate taste.” - Martin
“I tried a couple of other brands, but this is my favorite. High mushroom concentration and a great cocoa taste. In the morning I put a scoop in coffee, if I want more later I froth it in milk. I love it!” - William
| Feature | Noom | Laird Superfood | Four Sigmatic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cost per Serving | $1.33 | $0.55 | $1.33 |
| Mushrooms | Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Reishi, Cordyceps, Maitake, Shiitake | Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Maitake | Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Reishi, Turkey Tail |
| Nootropics | L-Tyrosine, Alpha GPC, Theanine, Mucuna, Huperzine A | None | None |
| Active Ingredients | 5,000 mg mushrooms / 750 mg nootropics | 2,000 mg mushrooms | 1,500 mg mushrooms |
| Caffeine Content | ~50mg per serving | Standard coffee caffeine level | ~50mg per serving (half-caf) |
| Flavor | Rich cacao-forward, smooth and creamy | Smooth, balanced medium roast | Medium roast with light caramel notes |
| Best For | Focus, energy, mood, full-body support | General wellness with traditional coffee flavor | Convenient gut and brain support without jitters |
What is Noom’s Nootropic Coffee?
We felt the mushroom coffee market needed a shakeup, so we designed our high-performance cocoa drink to fill in all the gaps other brands left in their blends.
While most other brands contain just 2,000mg of active ingredients and little to no nootropics, we give you more than 5,000mg of mushrooms (including Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Turkey Tail, and Shiitake) with 750mg of nootropics featuring Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, Guarana, and L-Tyrosine.
Additional support comes from adaptogens like Rhodiola, taurine for neuro-support, and L-Arginine for circulation. All these ingredients work in synergy to support mental clarity, smooth energy, and daily resilience, helping you feel and perform your best no matter the task at hand.
We’ve even included collagen peptides for skin, joint, and gut support, with cinnamon and cardamom for subtle warmth and flavor. Our brew intentionally leaves common ingredients out, too, like sugar, dairy, and artificial fillers.
Each scoop has 56mg of caffeine, sourced from natural ingredients like guarana and cordyceps, so you get that familiar buzz without the worry of jitters or an ensuing crash a few hours later. We let the mushrooms and nootropics do the heavy lifting for smooth energy.
The flavor is smooth, cocoa-forward, and mixes cleanly in hot or cold water. Don’t expect that bitter coffee flavor or any earthy mushroom taste in Noom. You’ll genuinely look forward to your next serving, every time.
It’s not the cheapest option between Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Laird, but it provides the best value for your money when you calculate how much good stuff you’re getting in every sip. With over 10,000 happy customers and counting, it’s taking the mushroom coffee market by storm.
What is Four Sigmatic’s Original Mushroom Coffee?
Four Sigmatic’s Original Mushroom Coffee was one of the first products to bring functional mushrooms into the coffee space, and it’s still here as one of the top choices today. It’s easy to see why when you look at what’s inside the bag.
The formula is built on organic, instant Arabica coffee, paired with five functional mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Reishi, Turkey Tail, and Cordyceps. Four Sigmatic rounds out the ritual with vitamin B12 (333% DV) and probiotics (Bacillus subtilis) to support brain function, energy metabolism, and gut health in a single scoop.
Simplicity sets Four Sigmatic apart from other brands. Just one tablespoon mixed into hot water gives you a half-caff dose (~50mg of caffeine), light mushroom support, and mild cognitive lift, no crash of traditional coffee whatsoever.
All mushrooms are fruiting body extracts (not mycelium), and the brand goes to great lengths to third-party test for mycotoxins and heavy metals. Quality is a cornerstone of everything Four Sigmatic offers.
The flavor is smooth and coffee-forward with light caramel notes, designed for people who want the taste of coffee without as much stimulation. Four Sigmatic is priced similarly to Noom, but the difference in value is jarring when you look at ingredient concentration. They have zero nootropics and only 1,500 mg of active ingredients.
What is Laird Superfood’s PERFORM Coffee?
Laird Superfood’s PERFORM Functional Mushroom Coffee combines specialty-grade organic Peruvian coffee beans with a blend of adaptogenic mushroom extracts.
It’s different from most other mushroom coffees in that it isn’t instant. You will have to brew it like you would any other coffee, either using a standard drip, pour over, or French press. This complicates the daily ritual, so Laird may not be right for those with a chaotic routine.
Laird adds four organic mushrooms after roasting and grinding the beans to a medium roast profile: Chaga, Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, and Maitake. The result is a smooth, complex coffee with no added flavors, mushroom taste, or functional dusting. Everything Laird sells is lab-tested and clean-label.
There are no added nootropics, collagen, or adaptogens beyond the mushroom blend. It’s a more minimalist take: a classic cup of coffee that just happens to be enhanced. You’ll get a lot more caffeine per serving at roughly 100 mg, so Laird also isn’t the ideal candidate if you’re trying to cut back on your intake and avoid jitters or the crash.
Laird is the cheapest per serving of our Four Sigmatic vs Laird vs Noom comparison, but again, we always prefer to look at cost per milligram as it’s a better indicator of value for the money. With no nootropics and only 2,000 mg of ingredients per serving, it falls short of Noom.
Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Laird: Which is the Best Mushroom Coffee For Your Daily Ritual?
We want to give credit where it’s due, as Four Sigmatic and Laird are two great brands producing functional mushroom coffee that gives you more than regular coffee ever could. But not all formulas are created with the same focus, ingredient quality, or intention.
While all three brands in our Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Laird comparison have earned their place in the market, we all approach the category a bit differently. We’ll break down key differences in ingredients (and concentration), potential benefits, taste, cost, and more.
Key Ingredients
Let’s start with what matters most: the mushrooms. Here’s a quick look at the specific varieties included in Laird Superfood vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom:
| Mushroom | Noom | Four Sigmatic | Laird |
|---|---|---|---|
| Lion’s Mane | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Reishi | ✔️ | ✔️ | ❌ |
| Chaga | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Cordyceps | ✔️ | ✔️ | ✔️ |
| Turkey Tail | ✔️ | ✔️ | ❌ |
| Shiitake | ✔️ | ❌ | ❌ |
| Maitake | ❌ | ❌ | ✔️ |
But, mushrooms aren’t the only ingredients you’ll find in each of these brews. All three brands round out their formulas with additional nootropics, adaptogens, and functional ingredients.
Here at Noom we lean heavily on nootropics to fuel peak productivity, smooth energy, and a healthier stress response. That’s why we include Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, Guarana, L-Tyrosine, Rhodiola, N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, Taurine, L-Arginine.
You’ll also get collagen peptides, cocoa powder, cinnamon, cardamom. Each serving includes roughly 56mg of caffeine per serving from the guarana and mushroom content.
Four Sigmatic takes a simpler approach with no added nootropics, an instant Arabica coffee base, vitamin B12, and Bacillus subtilis probiotic. You get roughly 50mg of caffeine per serving, right on par with our blend at Noom.
Laird Superfood’s PERFORM coffee is by far the most minimalist of the grouping, though. It’s just the mushrooms mentioned above with organic ground Peruvian coffee. That said, the caffeine content is double that of Noom and Four Sigmatic at roughly 100mg per serving.
Potency and Purity
It’s not just the specific ingredients that matter in comparing Laird Superfoods vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom. How much of those ingredients are included and where they come from needs to be taken into account as well.
Be clear, all three brands take quality seriously. We source full-spectrum fruiting body mushroom extracts here at Noom, which is where most of the real benefits from mushrooms reside.
Meanwhile, Four Sigmatic uses wildcrafted and log-grown mushrooms with no mycelium or grain filler. They also third-party test for heavy metals and mycotoxins so you can rest assured you’re getting a pure brew.
Laird also focuses on clean, organic sourcing, particularly for their coffee beans, which are grown at high altitude in the Peruvian mountains and roasted in-house.
But where things become more lopsided in comparing Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Laird is in potency. We offer substantially more active ingredients per serving:
- Noom: 5,000 mg of mushrooms + 750mg of nootropics
- Four Sigmatic: 2,000mg of mushrooms, no nootropics
- Laird Superfood: 1,500mg of mushrooms, no nootropics
Noom delivers more than double the functional content of the other two brands per scoop, and we’re the only one with clinically aligned nootropic support built in.
Potential Benefits
The real question most people have isn’t “what’s in it?” but “what does it do?” There’s quite a bit of overlap between Laird Superfood vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom here, because we have a lot of the same mushrooms.
All three brands can provide a cognitive lift with calm, sustained energy and a better mood. But since our formula is so much more potent, expect to feel more with Noom. More focus, more energy, more balanced. Our goal is to help you unlock your full potential through our brew.
Other potential benefits of these functional coffees include a stronger immune response, better digestive health, and antioxidant support. This is thanks to the functional mushrooms included, which are versatile superfoods.
The Enjoyment Factor
Be clear, the functional side of things matters most when comparing Four Sigmatic vs Laird vs Noom. But you need to enjoy the daily ritual, too. Otherwise, you won’t be consistent. And if you’re not consistent, you won’t reap the full benefits.
Both Four Sigmatic and Laird Superfood use a coffee base, but different types of coffee. Four Sigmatic tastes more like your favorite medium-roast instant coffee. There are subtle carmel undertones. Laird is a lot heavier on the coffee content, so it tastes stronger - which can be a good or bad thing depending on your preferences.
Noom is a bit different from Laird Superfood vs Four Sigmatic in that we don’t have any coffee content, so you won’t get that bitter taste. We use a cocoa-forward base that drinks like hot chocolate with a purpose.
It’s smooth, easy to mix with hot or cold water, and doesn’t leave behind grit or sediment. You won’t taste any sort of mushrooms, but there is a very mild earthiness if you look hard enough for it. Most of our customers say the flavoring masks it so they can’t taste it, though.
There are differences in preparation, though. Four Sigmatic and Noom mix easily in water without even needing a frother, whereas Laird Superfood needs to be brewed via a drip, pour-over, or French press setup. Again, this can be a pro or a con depending on how you view your daily ritual of brewing a cup of coffee.
Cost Comparison
There’s one more thing we need to look at in comparing Four Sigmatic vs Laird vs Noom: cost. More specifically, value. After all, Laird looks to be the most affordable on paper, but that’s not the case when you zoom in to view ingredient concentration:
- Noom: $1.33 per serving.
- Four Sigmatic: $1.33 per serving.
- Laird Superfood: $0.55 per serving.
All three brands offer subscribe-and-save options and bulk discounts, which can lower the per-serving price over time. But if you're measuring cost by what you get - not just what you pay - Noom delivers more functional value in every cup:
- Noom: $0.000266 per mg
- Four Sigmatic: $0.000886 per mg
- Laird Superfood: $0.000275 per mg
It’s easy to see why Noom is the #1 choice in comparing our blend to Laird Superfood vs Four Sigmatic. More good stuff per serving to help you feel and perform your best - that’s what it’s all about, right?
Wrapping Up Our Comparison of Laird Superfood vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom
Hopefully this three-way comparison of Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Laird Superfood has left you with complete clarity on where there’s overlap and where each brand has an edge over the others.
You can also compare RYZE vs Everyday Dose in our blog if you'd like, or check out some of the top AG1 alternatives and Mud WTR alternatives.
The key takeaway, though, is Noom offers more functional ingredients per serving than Laird and Four Sigmatic combined - and any other brands you could pit us against, for that matter. It’s by far the strongest formula and best value per scoop if you’re looking for a daily ritual that supports focus, mood, and energy without sacrificing enjoyment.
Don’t just take our word for it, though. Upgrade your mornings or afternoons with a smarter, more focused brew that does more than replace coffee. It helps you tap into your full potential. Shop Noom today!
“I can not say enough good things about your product, It has done everything you claimed it woould do and with just one serving a day with my breakfast, I will be purchasing more soon” - Bruce
“Almost through my 30 days and I was amazed at how much better I feel and was surprised how good it tastes.” - Robyn
“Great overall experience. I highly recommend this to anyone to try!” - Evanghelos