everyday dose vs mud wtr

Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR: How Do These Blends Compare to Noom?

You’re not alone if you’ve begun expecting more from your morning cup of joe or your afternoon pick-me-up. Traditional coffee doesn’t cut it anymore with far better options at your fingertips, such as mushroom and nootropic coffee blends.

But, it can be hard to narrow it down with so many great brews to choose from. One comparison we see made all the time is Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR. When you dig a bit deeper, though, they’re actually pretty different.

Everyday Dose is a mushroom coffee containing lion’s mane, chaga, collagen, L-theanine, and a full amino acid profile. On the other hand, Mud WTR has chaga, lion’s mane, reishi, cordyceps, chai, turmeric, cacao, cinnamon, and more.

So, how do these blends stack up to our own nootropic coffee here at Noom? You’ve come to the right place. We’ll highlight the most important nuances between Noom vs Mud WTR vs Everyday Dose so you can make the most informed decision for your daily routine.

The short answer, though, is our blend has WAY more functional content per serving (5,000mg compared to just 2,240-2,275mg). We’ve also included a lot more nootropics than Everyday Dose, while Mud WTR has none.

We think it’s the best blend on the market, and thousands of customers agree. But don’t just take our word for it. Try Noom risk-free today and discover the difference firsthand!

“I like the new Noom. Tastes much better but the big thing is the higher amount of essential ingredients that give me the mental boost I was looking for.” - Anthony

“I've been drinking mushroom coffee for almost a year now. I've had great success with them, having tried several brands. Noomtropics has got to be the best by far! One dose goes much farther than the others, plus I love the chocolate taste.” - Martin

“Excellent focus and no crash.” - Dominick

Mud WTR vs Everyday Dose vs Noom at a Glance

 

Feature

Noom

Everyday Dose

Mud WTR

Base

Cocoa + Collagen Peptides

Low-Acid Coffee Extract

Masala Chai (Black Tea Base)

Mushrooms

6 types: Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Turkey Tail, Shiitake

2 types: Lion’s Mane & Chaga

4 types: Chaga, Reishi, Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps

Nootropics

Alpha GPC, L-Theanine, Guarana, L-Tyrosine, N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, CDP-Choline

SunTheanine® (L-Theanine)

None

Adaptogens

Rhodiola

None

Turmeric, Cinnamon

Other Actives

Taurine, L-Arginine, Cinnamon, Cardamom

Collagen

None specified

Caffeine per serving

56 mg (from guarana + cocoa)

45 mg (from coffee extract)

35 mg (from black tea)

Taste Profile

Chocolate-forward with spice (no coffee flavor)

Mild, smooth coffee flavor with umami notes

Earthy chai with strong spice finish

Price per serving

$1.33

$1.20

$1.33

 

Noom Ingredients, Flavor, and Cost

Noom is a complete rethink of what your morning ritual can actually do for you. 

While other brands focus on one or two categories (like mushrooms or adaptogens), Noom goes further by combining three distinct pillars into one cohesive formula: functional mushrooms, clinically studied nootropics, and powerful adaptogens.

It’s formulated to support your brain, your mood, and your immunity without the trade-offs of traditional coffee or overly spiced mushroom drinks. Let’s take a closer look at what’s in every serving below:

What’s Inside the Noom Blend

Every serving of Noom includes a carefully balanced trio of:

  • Mushrooms: Lion’s mane, cordyceps, reishi, shiitake, chaga, and turkey tail. Each has been chosen for a specific purpose, from calm focus to smooth energy, gut healthy, immunity, and more. 
  • Nootropics: L-theanine, guarana, L-tyrosine, Alpha GPC, and other research-backed compounds for calm focus and sustained mental clarity.
  • Adaptogens: Rhodiola and L-arginine are included to support a stronger stress response and keep energy levels balanced.

Other ingredients include collagen peptides, cocoa powder, cinnamon, cardamom, and more. Everything is sourced, dosed, and blended intentionally to work together, not just coexist.

But the real kicker is just how much you’re getting per serving compared to similar brands. We’ve included more than double the functional ingredient content, so you’re getting far superior value for the money.

Taste That Doesn’t Need Masking

Let’s be honest: a lot of functional coffee alternatives taste like something you have to “get used to.” Noom skips the mud and mushroom funk entirely with a smooth, slightly rich flavor - closer to a clean cocoa than a health drink. 

There’s no overwhelming spice or gritty texture. It mixes easily with hot or cold liquids and plays well with your go-to milk or creamer. Most people describe it as “surprisingly drinkable,” but once you’ve tried it, you’ll just call it coffee. That’s the point.

Cost That Matches the Experience

We’re not the cheapest blend on the market, but that’s intentional. You get what you pay for, after all. Noom delivers the best value for the money when you consider the total functional ingredient content and the overall experience. 

We think it’s clear Noom is the better Everyday Dose and mud WTR alternative. But we’ll let you decide for yourself. Let’s take a closer look at Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR below.

Everyday Dose Ingredients, Flavor, and Cost

Everyday Dose is another compelling coffee alternative designed to reduce caffeine while adding functional benefits. The formula is pretty similar to ours at first glance: mushrooms, collagen peptides, and adaptogens. But you need to dig deeper to see the differences.

What’s Inside the Everyday Dose Blend

The mushroom component includes lion’s mane, chaga, and cordyceps, all commonly components in functional drinks for the focus, immunity, and endurance benefits they have to offer.

There’s also L-theanine, sourced from tea leaves, to help moderate the caffeine response. And instead of whole coffee, Everyday Dose uses a coffee extract (not instant coffee or ground beans) for a lighter caffeine profile around 39mg per serving.

The collagen content brings support for skin, joint, and hair. But you can see just how light the ingredients label looks compared to that of Noom. The real issue, though, is just how light the concentration is at only 2,275mg per serving.

How Does it Taste?

Everyday Dose is mild and noticeably less “coffee-like” than many expect. You’ll get a faint earthy mushroom note on its own, though many users add milk or creamer to round it out. 

The texture is smooth, especially compared to gritty adaptogen blends, and it dissolves fairly well in hot liquids. It’s not bad, but not remarkable either. 

The Cost Conversation

The functional brew looks really affordable on paper at only $25 for your first bag. But remember, you’re getting less than half the functional content compared to Noom. So when you think about what you’re actually getting, you’re paying more!

Mud WTR Ingredients, Flavor, and Cost

Mud WTR launched with the bold promise of being a coffee alternative without the crash, and it was one of the most prominent in this space at one point as a result of its strong marketing campaigns. The ads were impossible to get away from! But what’s really in it, and is it all it’s cracked up to be?

What’s Inside the Everyday Dose Blend

Its core blend combines masala chai, cacao, turmeric, cinnamon, sea salt, and four mushrooms: lion’s mane, chaga, reishi, and cordyceps. You also get a little caffeine from black tea (around 35mg per serving), which is way lower than coffee but still enough to feel a gentle lift.

Again, though, the actual functional content leaves a bit to be desired compared to more potent blends like ours at Noom. You’re getting just 2,240mg per serving.

How Does it Taste?

Mud WTR doesn’t try to mimic coffee. It’s a spicy, earthy blend that’s more tea-forward than roast-forward. You’ll find it familiar if you enjoy chai. But if you’re expecting something that resembles espresso, you’ll likely feel the flavor is out of left field.

We’ve read quite a few Mud WTR reviews, and one of the key takeaways is that the name fits the flavor unfortunately well. It’s often described as “muddy.” That said, you can mix it with oat milk or sweeteners to make it more palatable.

The Cost Conversation

This functional beverage sits at the higher end of the pricing spectrum at $40, and that’s actually the price reflecting a current sale (usually $60). 

Considering the ingredients are largely spices and tea with undisclosed mushroom amounts, the value here leans more into lifestyle branding and flavor experimentation than concentrated functional performance.

And remember, you’re paying MORE than you would for Noom, and getting LESS. That’s hard to justify when you consider all the other benefits our brew brings to your daily ritual. 

Our blog has additional resources comparing Mud WTR vs RYZE. We also have comparisons of

Everyday Dose vs RYZE or Everyday Dose vs Beyond Brew. But let’s narrow our focus to Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR vs Noom below. 

Mud WTR vs Everyday Dose vs Noom: Which is Right For You?

Finding the right coffee alternative depends on what you’re hoping to get from your cup. Whether you're looking to cut caffeine, support focus, nourish your body with adaptogens, or just enjoy a better ritual, each brand takes a slightly different approach to the problem.

So, let’s look at the five factors that matter most in choosing between Mud WTR vs Everyday Dose vs Noom - formula, potency, taste, caffeine, and cost. 

Formula and Ingredient Diversity

There is a bit of overlap in comparing Noom vs Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR in terms of ingredients. We all use chaga, lion’s mane, cordyceps, and a few carefully selected other nootropics/adaptogens. But let’s dig a bit deeper.

Mud WTR is a spice-heavy, caffeine-free base. Its core ingredients include four mushroom varieties (Chaga, Reishi, Cordyceps, Lions Mane), turmeric, cinnamon, cacao, and masala chai spices. What you’re not getting is any collagen, amino acids, or nootropics.

On the other hand, Everyday Dose has even fewer ingredients. It’s just Lion’s Mane and Cordyceps mushroom extracts with collagen and L-Theanine, along with a modest serving of caffeine from coffee extract. Just one nootropic, zero adaptogens.

This is ultimately what sets us apart the most. Not only do we have the most mushroom varieties (including Shiitake and Turkey Tail in addition to the usual suspects), but you’re getting collagen peptides, L-Theanine, L-Tyrosine, Taurine, Guarana, natural cocoa, and a proprietary nootropic blend with Alpha GPC.

It's not just a “mushroom coffee.” It’s a full-spectrum functional drink that supports focus, mood, performance, and overall wellness from every angle. The difference is noticeable from that first cup.

Ingredient Concentration

Now, it’s not just a matter of which blend has the better ingredient formulation between Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR vs Noom. The ingredient concentration matters, too. This is another area where our brew stands apart from the other two:

  • Mud WTR: 2,240mg
  • Everyday Dose: 2,275mg
  • Noom: 5,000mg

You could combine Mud WTR vs Everyday Dose, and you’d still be getting less functional content per serving! Why pay more for less? It just doesn’t make sense from our point of view. And as more customers realize what they’re really getting per serving, they’re making the jump.

Taste and Drinking Experience

You want a morning or afternoon ritual you genuinely look forward to. This is somewhat personal preference in choosing between Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR vs Noom, so it’s not fair to say one is “better” across the board than the others.

That said, most customers can agree Mud WTR sits a bit lower in terms of enjoyment. Some do appreciate the spice-forward profile - particulary those who enjoy chai with a slightly earthy undertone and don’t mind graininess. But it’s definitely not for everyone.

Everyday Dose tastes closer to a mild latte, albeit less bitter than traditional coffee since the coffee content is so much lower than typical java. It has some smoothness, especially when blended with milk.

Noom is in a league of its own, as it’s closer to hot cocoa than coffee. We included cinnamon and cardamom to create a rich, warming drinking experience. There’s no gritty texture common in mushroom drinks and it mixes well into water or milk. Don’t expect Noom to taste like coffee in the traditional sense - but it’s not trying to. 

Caffeine Content

Each of these blends has a very low caffeine content compared to traditional coffee. Mud WTR has 35mg of caffeine, Everyday Dose has 45mg of caffeine, and Noom has 56mg of caffeine. Yet again, you’re getting the best bang for your buck with Noom!

That said, some people prefer to avoid caffeine - and we get it. While the amount we include isn’t enough to cause jitters or a crash, here’s something you should be aware of: you can cut the dose in half to get down to just 28mg of caffeine, while STILL getting more functional content than Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR!

Price Per Serving and Overall Value

You shouldn’t choose between Mud WTR vs Everyday Dose vs Noom based on cost alone. You get what you pay for, after all. Rather, you should think about value for the money. 

Mud WTR costs about $1.33 per serving, while Everyday Dose is only $1.20 per serving. Noom is $1.33 per serving. But we’ve said it before, and we’ll say it once more: you’re getting WAY better value with our brew. 

Remember how much more functional content you get per serving in Noom. It’s a no-brainer when you look at cost through that lens. So, why settle for less than the best? Taste and feel the difference with Noom today. 

Wrapping Up Our Comparison of Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR

We hope you have a stronger grasp of which is right for you between Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR vs Noom. While all three have done something right to earn a reputation among the best mushroom beverage blends, there are subtle differences that set them apart.

Noom delivers a fuller blend: more mushrooms, more functional ingredients, and more transparency - all at roughly the same price point. Make the switch to something that actually does something and see what keeps customers coming back for more!

Back to blog