Some people love their morning cup of joe. Others expect more from their daily ritual, and have chosen to upgrade to something more functional. Something that delivers smooth, focused energy and whole-body health benefits without the jitters and ensuing crash.
Our nootropic coffee here at Noom checks every single box. But we see our blend compared to MUD WTR vs RYZE all the time, and have customers asking us how we stack up. So, we put together this RYZE vs MUD WTR vs Noom comparison so YOU can make your own decision!
All three brands do a great job formulating a beverage that goes above and beyond what traditional coffee ever could. There’s a bit of overlap in some areas, like mushrooms included (Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, and Reishi). But the differences become jarring as you dig deeper.
Noom is by far the best value for the money in that you get 5,000 mg of active ingredients per serving. RYZE only delivers 2,000 mg, while MUD WTR provides 2,240 mg. You’re getting less than half the functional dose with the other guys.
We also believe the formulation here at Noom is superior for people looking to perform their best every day, whether it’s in work, study, parenting, athletics - you name it, Noom can help you reach your full potential.
Learn more about the differences between MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom below!
“This is the best-tasting mushroom coffee I have tried. Great taste, no sweetener needed and seems to have good health qualities. I will be starting a subscription to this.” - Scott
“I tried a couple of other brands, but this is my favorite. High mushroom concentration and a great cocoa taste. In the morning I put a scoop in coffee, if I want more later I froth it in milk. I love it!” - William
“Almost through my 30 days and I was amazed at how much better I feel and was surprised how good it tastes.” - Robyn
Quick Look at RYZE Mushroom Coffee vs MUD WTR vs Noom
| Feature | Noom | RYZE | MUD WTR |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ingredients | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, Tyrosine, Rhodiola, Guarana | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, King Trumpet, Arabica coffee, MCT oil, coconut milk powder | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Cacao, masala chai, turmeric, cinnamon, salt |
| Functional Content per Serving | 5,000mg mushrooms + 750mg nootropics | ~2,000mg mushrooms | ~2,240mg mushrooms |
| Cost per Serving | $1.33 | $1.20 | $1.33 |
| Cost per mg of Functional Ingredients | $0.00022 | $0.00060 | $0.00059 |
| Taste & Texture | Cocoa-forward, smooth, no grit | Creamy, nutty, mild grit at bottom | Earthy, spicy, often gritty |
| Caffeine Content | ~56mg (natural sources) | ~48mg (coffee-based) | ~35mg |
| Best For | Focus, calm energy, mental clarity | Light wellness with latte-like feel | Mindful ritual with lower caffeine |
Overview of Noom
Noom is a functional, cocoa-based beverage for those who want more than caffeine and low-dosed mushrooms in their morning brew. We built our blend with performance as the main priority.
As a result, you get a generous 5,000mg of functional mushroom extracts and 750mg of nootropics in every serving. It’s the most concentrated formula on the market. The mushroom profile includes:
- Lion’s Mane
- Reishi
- Chaga
- Cordyceps
- Shiitake
- Turkey Tail
You also get more body- and brain-boosting ingredients such as Alpha-GPC for focus, L-Theanine for calm clarity, Tyrosine and Rhodiola for mental stamina and mood support, and natural caffeine sources like Guarana and Cordyceps (totaling about 56mg per serving).
The formula also includes collagen peptides, cinnamon, cardamom, and cocoa. These play their own role, not just in flavor enhancement, but in supporting joint health, circulation, and inflammation balance.
Noom is sugar-free, gluten-free, dairy-free, and easy to mix with hot or cold water. It’s trusted by more than 10,000 happy customers and counting with a 4.9/5 star rating. Get measurable energy, clarity, and enjoyment in one cup - or learn more about RYZE vs MUD WTR below.
Overview of MUD WTR
MUD WTR is one of the most recognizable names in the mushroom coffee space because this brand was among the first to do it. The company became a household name through its social media advertising efforts, and still to this day has its place in the functional beverage category.
The drink itself is known for its distinctive, earthy, spiced flavor - it’s definitely not coffee. It was created for coffee drinkers looking to reduce caffeine intake while still feeling focused and awake. So what’s inside? Mushrooms include:
- Lion’s Mane
- Reish
- Chaga
- Cordyceps
You’ll also find a moderate serving of turmeric, cinnamon, Himalayan salt, masala chai, and cacao. You’re getting roughly 35mg of caffeine per serving so it’s way less stimulation than traditional coffee - and really, not enough to even feel a lift at all.
Rather, it’s the synergy of mushrooms and spices that promote a calm sense of alertness and gut-friendly energy. There are no nootropics in the formula, though, which is an important distinction as we move forward in this comparison of MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom.
Still, MUD WTR is fully vegan, gluten-free, organic, and Whole30 approved. It’s a great choice for anyone who values clean labels and minimal processing. That said, a lot of people say the name couldn’t be more appropriate. The taste is really hard to get used to.
Overview of RYZE
RYZE is a true mushroom coffee, as it’s the only blend in our RYZE vs MUD WTR vs Noom comparison that actually has coffee in the blend! More specifically, you get Organic Arabica Coffee for roughly 48mg of caffeine in every serving.
That said, the mushrooms are where the real magic occurs for RYZE - and what the blend is better known for. The company calls the SUPER6TM blend the most sophisticated on the market:
- Lion’s Mane
- Shiitake
- Reishi
- Cordyceps
- Turkey Tail
- King Trumpet
The total functional content comes in at roughly 2,000 mg per serving. The biggest issue we have with this formula, though, is you can’t really see how much of each mushroom is in the blend - or where exactly the mushrooms come from.
Two other ingredients are MCT oil and coconut milk powder, which add healthy fats along with a creamy, nutty finish that many customers love, although others call it “gritty” and “earthy” to a fault.
There are also non-caffeinated beverages at RYZE if coffee isn’t your cup of tea (pun intended). All drinks are vegan, gluten-free, non-GMO, and sugar-free, and the company itself is backed by over 250,000 five-star reviews.
RYZE is one of the biggest in this space. That’s for sure. Is it best, though? Let’s take a closer look at RYZE vs MUD WTR vs Noom to help you choose the right daily drink for your regimen!
MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom: Key Differences to Consider as You Choose Your Daily Drink
Everyone has different taste preferences and wellness goals, so it’s important to take this breakdown of MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom with a grain of salt. Really, the best way to choose is to try all three and then think about which formula actually works best for your needs.
That said, we can help you narrow it down to just one brand by comparing ingredients (formula AND concentration), taste/texture, sourcing standards, value for the money, and other factors. Here’s what you need to know about Noom vs RYZE vs MUD WTR.
Specific Ingredients Chosen
All three brands use functional mushrooms, and you’ll see familiar faces on all three labels. There are some importance nuances, though:
- Noom Mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Turkey Tail
- MUD WTR Mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga
- RYZE Mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, King Trumpet
So if you’re really interested in tapping into the mushroom magic, you’ll be better off going with Noom or RYZE. Mushrooms are just the tip of the iceberg for these brands, though. It’s also where Noom really pulls ahead of MUD WTR vs RYZE.
We include a full nootropic stack featuring Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, Guarana, Tyrosine, Rhodiola, and others. Neither RYZE nor MUD WTR include any of these.
Now, MUD WTR does have its own specific ingredients label which has spices like turmeric and cinnamon for flavor and light anti-inflammatory effects. RYZE brings you a more physically stimulating effect with Organic Arabica Coffee.
But, it’s clear which brand has the most functional ingredients label in comparing Noom vs RYZE vs MUD WTR. But what about ingredient concentration?
Ingredient Quality and Concentration
This is one of the most important differences between MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom, because it speaks to how much support you actually get for your body and mind in every serving:
- Noom: 5,000mg mushrooms + 750mg nootropics per serving
- RYZE: ~2,000mg mushrooms per serving
- MUD WTR: ~2,240mg mushrooms per serving
Noom delivers more than double the functional content of RYZE or MUD WTR. That difference matters if you’re looking for meaningful effects, be it for cognitive function in the workplace or physical performance in athletics.
Taste and Texture
You need a daily ritual you can stick to, which is why the taste and texture could be just as significant to your decision as the other factors above. Flavor preferences are very personal, though, so it’s important to keep that in mind.
One thing we know for sure is MUD WTR has a very polarizing flavor profile. Its earthy and spicy blend is contentious. Some love it, but most don’t. Words we see used to describe it include “gritty” or “bitter.”
On the other hand, RYZE is more familiar to coffee drinkers. It’s like your favorite latte, but with a nutty, earthy twist. Smooth and creamy are words we see used to describe it. That said, complaints around sediment in the bottom of the cup are very common.
Our cocoa-forward base here at Noom eliminates any sort of bitterness from the mushrooms. Our customers absolutely love the taste. But what they really appreciate is how effortlessly the ingredients dissolve in the mug. No grit left behind for you to chew on at the end of your drink!
All three products come as instant powders and mix easily into hot water. None require a brewing setup, and all can work with cold liquids if desired. MUD WTR recommends a frother, but Noom and RYZE mix cleanly enough to keep your routine fast and simple even without one.
Testing and Transparency
Ingredient quality isn’t just about what’s on the label. It’s how brands prove it. Trust is everything when you’re adding something to your daily regimen, after all. We don’t take that lightly, which is why Noom provides third-party testing for purity, potency, and absence of contaminants.
We’re also very transparent about how we extract our mushrooms and the exact functional content in every serving. We wish other brands would uphold our same standards for transparency.
Unfortunately, you won’t see the same in looking at RYZE and MUD WTR. They leave the specific mushroom dosage vague (we have to imagine purposefully). Proprietary blends are a good way to disguise underformulation, after all!
Value for the Money
You shouldn’t make the decision between MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom based on cost alone. Value for the money is what really matters. On paper, the differences are marginal:
- MUD WTR: $40
- RYZE: $36
- Noom: $39.99
But look closer at what you’re really getting. Noom delivers far more for the money on a per-milligram basis, more than twice as much functional content per dollar. Factor in the nootropics and supporting ingredients we’ve called upon, and we think it’s a no-brainer decision.
Parting Thoughts on RYZE vs MUD WTR
We hope this detailed overview of MUD WTR vs RYZE vs Noom has left you with complete clarity on the key differences in these blends and ultimately, which best suits your needs.
Our blog has similar comparisons of Four Sigmatic vs Laird and Everyday Dose vs RYZE. But whether you’re looking for a RYZE or MUD WTR alternative, or even an AG1 alternative, your search ends at Noom.
Across the board, you’ll find that our ingredients label is superior to the rest, and you get way more functional support per serving at a lower price. Make your mornings count or your afternoons smoother with a drink that works as hard as you do at Noom!