You’re not alone if you’re looking for a more functional beverage to start your day or reset your afternoon. Traditional coffee leaves people feeling tired but wired, and can cause jitters that ultimately just make matters worse. That’s the appeal of Four Sigmatic mushroom coffee.
This brew takes real, premium coffee and blends it with 5 carefully chosen mushrooms to encourage stronger focus and stress relief. It even brings benefits such as gut balance and immune support to your routine!
The brand has earned over 100,000 positive reviews and served up more than 200 million cups of its mushroom coffee. But it’s definitely not for everyone, and you probably already know that if you’re here looking for Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives.
Maybe you just don’t like the coffee base and want something that tastes better. Or perhaps you’ve come to realize just how little functional support you’re actually getting in every serving. Regardless, we’ve compiled a list of the best Four Sigmatic alternatives for you:
- Noom
- Everyday Dose
- Laird Superfoods
- RYZE
- MUD WTR
Each of these has earned its place in this conversation, but what is the best alternative to Four Sigmatic mushroom coffee? Look no further than Noom’s nootropic coffee. It provides 5,000 mg of functional ingredients, including 750 mg of nootropics, compared to the 1,500 mg you get with Four Sigmatic.
This brew has a cocoa-forward flavor since there’s no coffee, but you still get a subtle caffeine kick from natural sources like Guarana. You get most of the same mushrooms, but in much higher concentrations and with way more supportive ingredients.
Don’t settle for less in your daily routine - see for yourself what Noom can do for you!
“I really find this product delicious. One of the tastiest mushroom coffees I've tried yet.” - Brian
“I can not say enough good things about your product, It has done everything you claimed it would do and with just one serving a day with my breakfast, I will be purchasing more soon” - Bruce
“Great overall experience. I highly recommend this to anyone to try!” - Evanghelos
Fast Facts on Four Sigmatic Alternatives
| Brand | Functional Ingredients | Total Functional Content | Nootropics | Caffeine | Flavor & Texture | Value per mg |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Noom | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Shiitake, Turkey Tail + full nootropic stack | 5,000mg mushrooms + 750mg nootropics | ✔️ Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, Tyrosine, Rhodiola, Guarana | ~56mg (coffee-free) | Cocoa-forward, smooth, no grit | $0.00023/mg |
| Four Sigmatic | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga, Turkey Tail + B12, probiotics | ~1,500mg mushrooms | ❌ None | ~50mg (instant coffee) | Mellow coffee, caramel notes | $0.00089/mg |
| Everyday Dose | Lion’s Mane, Chaga, collagen, L-Theanine | ~2,275mg mushrooms + 300mg L-Theanine | ✔️ L-Theanine (light) | ~45mg (coffee-based) | Smooth, mild coffee-chocolate | $0.00047/mg |
| Laird Superfoods | Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Maitake | ~2,000mg mushrooms | ❌ None | ~100mg (brewed coffee) | Classic brewed coffee, smooth | $0.00028/mg |
| RYZE | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, King Trumpet | ~2,000mg mushrooms | ❌ None | ~48mg (coffee-based) | Creamy, nutty, mild grit | $0.00060/mg |
| MUD WTR | Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Chaga + cacao, turmeric, chai spices | ~2,240mg mushrooms | ❌ None | ~35mg (coffee-free) | Earthy, spiced, gritty | $0.00059/mg |
What is Four Sigmatic Coffee?
Four Sigmatic is one of the brands credited with introducing mushroom coffee to the mainstream market, combining traditional coffee with functional mushrooms to create a more balanced and gut-friendly morning ritual. It paved the way for other brands like RYZE, MUD WTR, and more.
The company’s flagship product, the Original Mushroom Coffee, is an instant, medium-roast Arabica coffee infused with a proprietary blend of adaptogenic mushrooms and added functional compounds.
The mushrooms are the stars of the show, featuring Lion’s Mane, Turkey Tail, Chaga, Reishi, and Cordyceps. Four Sigmatic is clear about where the mushrooms come from: fruiting body only, no mycelium. After all, the fruiting body is where the good stuff actually comes from.
Other ingredients include Vitamin B12, probiotics, coconut milk powder, and yacon juice powder. The brand has since launched new variations of its mushroom coffee, like blends tailored specifically to focus, others angled at gut health. There are half-caf, high-caf, and decaf options.
The company emphasizes clean sourcing and testing with organic ingredients and third-party checks for toxins like heavy metals and mold. We also appreciate how Four Sigmatic goes above and beyond to preserve our planet with smarter packaging options.
Flavor is an important part of the Four Sigmatic philosophy, too. You need to actually enjoy something in order to stick with it, and customers say they enjoy the smooth, medium body with light caramel notes. It tastes like coffee without strong mushroom or herbal undertones.
Yet, Four Sigmatic isn’t right for everyone. There’s a reason we have so many customers coming to Noom looking for Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives…
Why Some Customers May Want Four Sigmatic Alternatives
It’s not that Four Sigmatic doesn’t work or is a “bad” product. It clearly has its place with over 200 million cups served so far. But nothing is one-size-fits-all, including mushroom coffee.
Some customers feel underwhelmed by the amount of functional ingredients they actually get per serving, especially relative to the cost per bag. Others find the flavor off-putting.
Whether you’ve tried Four Sigmatic yourself and weren’t impressed or just want to weigh your options before choosing a more functional replacement for your morning cup of coffee, here are a few common themes we found in customer reviews.
Looking for Higher Functional Content
Four Sigmatic contains about 1,500mg of mushrooms per serving. That’s very low compared to some of the Four Sigmatic alternatives we’ll share below. Others have at least 2,000mg, while some have 2,250mg.
But the best alternative to Four Sigmatic has 5,000mg of active ingredients! That’s more than triple the functional support, which matters when you’re looking for a solution to support stronger focus, clarity, and overall wellbeing.
Wanting Added Nootropics or Adaptogens
Four Sigmatic focuses solely on mushrooms, B12, and probiotics. There are no targeted nootropics or additional adaptogens that can enhance focus, mood, or stress resilience.
Don’t get us wrong, mushrooms can be powerful on their own. But to us, they’re just one piece of the puzzle. Many Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives combine their blends with other cognitive-supporting compounds for a more comprehensive effect.
Different Taste and Base Options
Four Sigmatic appeals to traditional coffee drinkers with its classic coffee base. Again, though, not everyone likes the acidic flavor profile coffee is known for. There’s a blend designed for you if you want something for smoother, less bitter daily drinking.
Cost Considerations
Four Sigmatic isn’t cheap compared to traditional coffee, but we want to make it clear that you get what you pay for. At $50 per bag, though, you would probably expect a bit more functional support than 1,500mg of mushrooms per serving.
That works out to roughly $1.67 per serving. Now, you can save money by subscribing to regular reorders or purchasing multi-packs. But for context, there are Four Sigmatic alternatives that cost between $0.55 to $1.33 per serving - while delivering WAY more ingredients per cup!
What Are the Best Alternatives to Four Sigmatic Mushroom Coffee?
You like the idea of functional mushrooms in your morning drink but feel Four Sigmatic falls short in potency, transparency, or overall experience. The good news is there are plenty of Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives to choose from.
So what are the best alternatives to Four Sigmatic mushroom coffee? Let’s narrow it down to just a single alternative that checks every box: Noom.
Noom
Noom blows every other brand out of the water with a functional drink that actually performs - because we didn’t skimp on ingredients! Every serving delivers 5,000mg of functional mushrooms, over three times the amount found in Four Sigmatic.
The blend consists of Lion’s Mane for sharp focus, Reishi for stress support, Cordyceps for natural energy, Chaga for immunity, and Shiitake and Turkey Tail for gut and immune balance. Each was chosen for its research-backed benefits.
But the mushrooms are just half the story. You also get a 750mg nootropic stack for even more cognitive clarity and performance. That includes Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, Tyrosine, Rhodiola, and Guarana, which all work in synergy to support memory, mental clarity, and calm energy.
You get focus without the jitters in our blend, but there is a slight caffeine lift from natural sources (like guarana, cordyceps). It’s just 56mg per serving so you won’t have to worry about a spike and crash in energy.
Noom’s cocoa-forward base offers a smooth, rich flavor without bitterness or grit - something our customers genuinely look forward to enjoying every day. There’s no actual coffee, which is an important distinction for those seeking Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives.
Every scoop of Noom is clearly labeled, tested for purity, and thoughtfully formulated to deliver meaningful benefits. We think it’s a smart upgrade from Four Sigmatic, but we’ll let you be the judge. Order yours today knowing it’s backed by our 30-day satisfaction guarantee!
Everyday Dose
Looking for a lighter, more approachable introduction to functional coffee? You may find Everyday Dose to be one of the better Four Sigmatic alternatives. You can keep your existing morning ritual intact if you currently enjoy your cup of coffee, but give it a slight boost with some added wellness benefits.
The formula combines Arabica coffee with Lion’s Mane and Chaga mushrooms, plus collagen peptides for joint and skin health, and a small dose of L-Theanine for calm focus.
It’s more concentrated than Four Sigmatic with 2,275mg of functional ingredients per serving and about 300mg of nootropics. That said, it’s a lot less than the support you get in Noom - so you’re ultimately settling for something underdosed in comparison.
The taste is mild and smooth, leaning toward a familiar coffee profile with subtle chocolate notes thanks to the added mushrooms. We think it’s great for coffee drinkers who want something gentler on the stomach and less acidic without straying too far from what they know.
But, you’re not getting the same level of cognitive support you could in some of these other Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives. It’s great for overall wellness, but falls short in encouraging stronger concentration.
Laird Superfoods
Laird Superfoods PERFORM coffee is a straightforward choice for traditional coffee drinkers who want a subtle functional boost without changing their brewing habits.
This ground coffee blends high-altitude, organic Peruvian beans with four mushrooms (Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, and Maitake) for cognitive and immune support that goes above and beyond what traditional coffee could ever do alone.
You get around 2,000mg of mushrooms per serving, which is a bit more than Four Sigmatic but still less than you need to really notice a lift on a daily basis. That said, you get what you pay for. It’s one of the cheapest alternatives to Four Sigmatic mushroom coffee at just $0.55 per serving.
The taste is one of its biggest strengths, though. It’s smooth, balanced, and approachable with a medium roast blend. There’s no overpowering mushroom flavor.
One major consideration, though, is you do have to brew Laird’s PERFORM coffee - it’s not a ready-to-drink mix. This can add complexity and stress to an already hectic morning routine.
The formula is also a bit lacking in comparison to other Four Sigmatic alternatives on this list. In comparing Four Sigmatic vs Laird to Noom, for instance, you get something more convenient and powerful!
RYZE
One of the most popular Four Sigmatic coffee alternatives is RYZE, and it’s easy to see why. This is perhaps the most popular mushroom coffee on the market right now, and the brand has earned over 250,000 five-star reviews.
The SUPER6TM Mushroom Blend is the heart of the formula. It consists of Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Turkey Tail, and King Trumpet, each chosen to support cognition, stress response, gut balance, immunity, and more.
This concoction is paired with organic Arabica coffee, MCT oil, and coconut milk powder. Together, these ingredients deliver roughly 2,000mg of functional mushrooms per serving, with no added nootropics or adaptogens. Just mushrooms and coffee.
This is a compelling choice if you want a creamy, coffee-based mushroom drink that feels more like a latte with a nutty flavor profile. One of the major red flags we see in reviews, though, is that RYZE can be a bit gritty at the bottom of the cup. Keep that in mind.
It’s also important to note that RYZE is light on functional content compared to other options and lacks a nootropic component entirely. You can get almost the exact same mushroom blend (albeit double the functional content) with supportive nootropics in Noom.
MUD WTR
MUD WTR is one of the more unique alternatives to Four Sigmatic mushroom coffee in that it doesn’t have any coffee content whatsoever, kind of like our blend here at Noom.
Instead, the brand has built a following around its unique, coffee-free blend of mushrooms, cacao, and spices. You get Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Cordyceps, and Chaga (about 2,240mg total), paired with cacao, masala chai spices, turmeric, cinnamon, and Himalayan salt.
Caffeine content is lighter at just 35mg of caffeine per serving, which can be a good or bad thing depending on how you feel about the stimulatory effect it has.
The drink is earthy, spiced, and polarizing. We’ve seen some fans say they appreciate its complexity and mindful vibe, while others find the flavor bitter and gritty. The name MUD WTR really does seem to be aptly chosen.
But taste and texture aside, there’s a reason Noom is the smarter Four Sigmatic alternative and MUD WTR alternative. You get more than double the functional content and additional nootropics in every serving. So, why settle for anything less when the best is just a click away?
Closing Thoughts on the Best Four Sigmatic Coffee Alternatives
Choosing the best Four Sigmatic alternatives can be stressful with so many options at your fingertips. We hope this comparison guide has helped you narrow it down to the perfect fit for your tastes and needs.
Whether you’re comparing Everyday Dose vs RYZE or looking for an AG1 alternative, remember that the best way to tap into the magic of functional mushrooms and nootropics is right here at Noom.
We deliver more of what you’re looking for in every single serving, and a cocoa-forward taste that you’ll look forward to every single morning or afternoon.
Upgrading your morning ritual doesn’t have to mean giving up convenience or taste. Get the best of both worlds in a functional drink that actually performs at Noom today!