There are more mushroom coffees on the market than ever before as people are running to replace their morning cup of joe with something smarter, gentler, and more functional. But this can make it tough to narrow it down to the best brand for your goals and preferences.
We see Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose compared all the time, and it’s easy to see why. There’s a bit of overlap in terms of formulation and flavor profile. Both contain real coffee with lion’s mane and chaga. But there are some subtle differences you should be aware of.
It’s also important to note that our nootropic coffee at Noom actually brings you more mushrooms per serving than anything else on the market. Not just in terms of varieties, but in concentration. We combine lion’s mane and chaga with shiitake, turkey tail, cordyceps, and reishi. You get 5,000mg of mushrooms compared to just 1,500mg-2,275mg for the others.
That’s not all, though, we also added 750mg of nootropics to take the functional benefits even further. With guarana, L-theanine, L-tyrosine, Alpha GPC, rhodiola, and more, you’re getting the most sophisticated, well-rounded brew available.
Learn more about Noom vs Everyday Dose vs Four Sigmatic below, or simply experience the difference firsthand by placing your order risk-free today!
“Completely switched from coffee. This doesn’t stain your teeth! I’ve shared this with several people, I’m a believer— and it tastes delicious!!” - Mitchel
“Noom is my go to morning mushroom coffee. I add a little oat milk, froth, and savor every sip!” - Jessica
“Have tried 5 different versions of mushroom products and this one stands out. Potency is awesome and flavor is great!” - Jason
Quick Comparison of Everyday Dose vs Four Sigmatic
|
Factor |
Noom Nootropic Coffee |
Four Sigmatic (Focus) |
Everyday Dose (Mushroom Coffee+) |
|
Base beverage |
Cocoa-based functional drink (not coffee) |
100% coffee (Arabica beans) |
Coffee-forward “elixir” (lighter than regular coffee) |
|
Preparation |
Instant mix: scoop → hot water or milk → stir |
Brew required (French press, pour-over, or drip) |
Instant mix: scoop → hot or cold liquid → stir |
|
Mushroom content per serving |
5,000 mg across Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Reishi, Shiitake, Turkey Tail |
1,500 mg across Lion’s Mane and Chaga |
2,275 mg across Lion’s Mane and Chaga |
|
Nootropics per serving |
750 mg (Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, Rhodiola Rosea, Guarana, Taurine) |
None added beyond mushrooms + caffeine |
150 mg L-Theanine |
|
Caffeine per serving |
~56 mg (from guarana) |
~100–125 mg (from brewed coffee; varies by method) |
~45 mg (from coffee) |
|
Collagen |
Yes (with cocoa; thicker, richer mouthfeel) |
No |
Yes (≈4 g per serving) |
|
Flavor & texture |
Smooth, unsweetened cocoa with subtle earthiness; dissolves cleanly; slightly thicker body |
Bold, nutty dark-roast coffee aroma and taste; classic brew experience |
Mellow, creamy, low-bitterness; latte-like and easy mixing |
|
Regular price per bag |
$35 |
$40 (32 servings) or $20 (16 servings) |
$52 (often discounted in promotions) |
|
Approx. price per serving (regular) |
$1.16 |
$1.33 |
$1.20 |
What is Noom Nootropic Coffee?
Noom Nootropic Coffee isn’t just mushroom coffee. In fact, it’s not really coffee at all - it just coexists in that space. We use cocoa instead, and let the mushrooms and nootropics do the heavy lifting. Let’s take a closer look at the ingredients and experience you’ll get below.
Overview of Ingredients and Potency
Every serving of Noom Nootropic Coffee includes 5,000mg of functional mushrooms: Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps, Reishi, Chaga, Shiitake, and Turkey Tail. This is the most well-rounded, potent mushroom blend on the market. But you also get:
- Alpha-GPC
- L-Theanine
- L-Tyrosine
- Rhodiola Rosea
- Taurine
- Guarana
That’s 750mg of nootropics - way more than anything other blend you’ll come across in the functional beverage space. In fact, most mushroom coffees don’t include any nootropics. Other ingredients include collagen peptides, cocoa, cinnamon, and cardamom.
The Drinking Experience
We said it before, and we’ll say it again: Noom isn’t trying to mimic black coffee. It’s more like a smooth, unsweetened cocoa with an earthy finish. Some people drink it straight with hot water; others prefer mixing it into milk or blending it into smoothies.
The texture is slightly thicker than standard coffee due to the collagen and cocoa powder. It dissolves cleanly with hot liquid and doesn’t leave sediment at the bottom like some mushroom powders. You’ll genuinely enjoy indulging in a cup (or two!) every day.
The Cost Conversation
Each bag of Noom contains 30 servings and retails for $35, though you can save even more by buying more than one bag or subscribing to regular reorders.
Here’s the thing, though - it’s already the most economical choice in our comparison of Noom vs Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose because you get more than double the functional content at roughly the same price point!
This alone is enough to tell you what your next steps should be in choosing between Everyday Dose vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom. But if you want to take a closer look at the other guys, keep reading below.
What is Four Sigmatic Mushroom Coffee?
Four Sigmatic’s mushroom coffee has earned over 100,000 five-star reviews with more than 200 million cups served. It’s the original mushroom coffee - but as you’ll soon find out, that doesn’t mean it’s the best option.
Overview of Ingredients and Potency
There are actually quite a few different varieties available at Four Sigmatic, so we’ll narrow our attention to the “Focus” blend. It pairs organic Arabica beans with two specific mushrooms: Lion’s Mane and Chaga. Both are extracted (not just powdered).
The caffeine content isn't stripped or softened. You’re getting a full-strength brew (around 100-125 mg of caffeine per serving depending on how you brew it), which gives you the mental boost of traditional coffee with the added benefit of functional ingredients.
Now, that can be a good thing for someone who loves traditional coffee but wants a bit more functional support to go with it. However, those who find coffee overwhelming in terms of taste or jitters, or don’t want a crash, may see this as a drawback.
The Drinking Experience
This is coffee-first in flavor. It smells, brews, and tastes like what you’d expect from a decent single-origin dark roast: bold, slightly nutty, and full-bodied.
The biggest difference between Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose vs Noom in terms of the drinking experience is that this one actually has to be brewed, either via a French press, pour-over, or drip machine. That’s a bit more work than it may be worth for some people.
The Cost Conversation
Four Sigmatic isn’t cheap at $40 per bag (32 servings), but you do have the option to save 30% through a subscription plan. You could also dip your toes in the water with a 16-serving pack for only $20.
But keep in mind you’re only getting 1,500mg of functional ingredients per serving - so even at the higher price point, you’re getting way less actual support from Four Sigmatic.
This is why we feel pretty strongly Noom is among the best Four Sigmatic alternatives. You get more for less. That said, let’s look at the other half of our Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose comparison below.
What is Everyday Dose Mushroom Coffee?
Everyday Dose plays a different hand in that it contains some coffee, but far less than Four Sigmatic. Think of it more as a smart morning elixir designed for people who like coffee but don’t want the crash or the edge.
Overview of Ingredients and Potency
Each serving of Mushroom Coffee+ combines Lion’s Mane and Chaga extracts (1,500 mg total), L-Theanine (150 mg), and collagen peptides (4 grams), all wrapped in a smooth-tasting coffee base with about 45 mg of caffeine per scoop.
That’s less than half the caffeine of a regular cup, but the goal here isn’t stimulation - it’s balance. The coffee provides a subtle lift, the L-theanine takes the edge off, and the mushrooms do some of the heavy lifting for focus and endurance.
But, the formulation is a bit lackluster compared to that of Noom - it’s only two mushrooms with a single nootropic. While it’s more than you get with Four Sigmatic, it falls short in our opinion. That said, the 2,275mg functional content per serving is quite the step up from Four Sigmatic.
The Drinking Experience
Flavor-wise, Everyday Dose leans more mellow than bold. It’s creamy, smooth, and mixes easily with hot or cold water. There’s no bitterness, mushroom funk, or chalky residue if you stir it right. It's like a mild latte without dairy.
But, you don’t have to brew anything with Everyday Dose. It’s ready to drink. Just mix it up and enjoy! It’s a more convenient format compared to Four Sigmatic.
The Cost Conversation
Everyday Dose is the most affordable option on paper at only $25 per serving (it’s usually priced at $52, but the brand is running a sale right now). That’s $0.83 per serving.
Remember, though, you’re getting less than half the functional content that you would with Noom. So technically, you’re paying more in the long run. But cost isn’t everything, and we are all for paying a premium for quality.
That said, let’s put Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose vs Noom side by side by side below.
Everyday Dose vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom: Tips on Choosing the Right Brew for Your Goals
Picking between Everyday Dose vs Four Sigmatic vs Noom isn’t like choosing a flavor. You’re determining which daily ritual will support you best.
There’s a lot to consider here, from the ingredients themselves to concentration, caffeine content, the drinking experience, and more. So let’s not waste any time!
Mushroom Profile
Both Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose hone in on only two mushrooms, and they’re actually the same varieties: Lion’s Mane and Chaga. Lion’s Mane is frequently used for cognitive support, while Chaga is often included for antioxidant support.
While simplicity can often be a good thing, this is not one of those cases. We here at Noom take a far more well-rounded approach with Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Reishi, and Turkey Tail.
Each of these brings something special to your daily ritual, be it gut health or mood support, immunity, physical energy, and more. If you’re going to try a mushroom coffee, why not go with MORE mushrooms?
Speaking of more mushrooms, Noom delivers 5,000mg of functional ingredients in every serving. For comparison, Everyday Dose and Four Sigmatic only offer 2,275mg and 1,500mg, respectively. So they’re lacking in terms of variety and potency.
Nootropic Additions
Here’s where the formulas really split paths in looking at Everyday Dose vs Four Sigmatic and Noom. Four Sigmatic doesn’t include any traditional nootropics. It’s literally just mushrooms and coffee.
Everyday Dose, on the other hand, contains a single nootropic in L-theanine. It’s actually one of the only blends on the market that has any nootropics, so kudos there! But this formula pales in comparison to our nootropic stack at Noom:
- Alpha-GPC
- L-Theanine
- N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine
- Rhodiola Rosea
- Guarana
- Taurine
Whether you’re struggling with brain fog or just want to perform better throughout the day, you’ll feel the difference with 750mg of nootropics in every cup of Noom.
Caffeine Content
Four Sigmatic stays close to regular coffee, delivering 100-125 mg of caffeine per serving depending on how you brew. It’s best for people who want their functional ingredients but still enjoy that strong, classic caffeine hit.
Everyday Dose and Noom cut the content in half with roughly 45mg and 56mg of caffeine per serving, respectively. That’s intentional. We think caffeine can be helpful, but it’s often overused. A full serving of coffee typically leads to jitters and a crash, which is the last thing you need.
The difference between Noom and Everyday Dose is in terms of where the caffeine is derived from. It comes from coffee for Everyday Dose, and guarana extract for us.
Flavor Profile and Texture
One of the biggest differences between Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose comes down to the brewing experience.
The former is traditional coffee in the sense you need to use a French press or drip machine, which can be a bit of a hassle. But, it’s worth it if you love a classic dark roast, and the ritual that goes into brewing your morning mug.
Everyday Dose is more like a wellness drink than traditional coffee. It mixes into hot water like a latte powder. It’s smooth, creamy, and mellow. It doesn’t have the bitter, acidic notes of regular coffee, and the texture is surprisingly silky.
Noom is in a class of its own here, as it doesn't have any coffee in it. Instead, we’ve gone with cocoa to concoct a beverage that’s like a functional hot chocolate. It’s delightfully sweet and incredibly easy to prepare on a daily basis. Scoop, stir, sip, enjoy!
What You’re Really Paying For
Cost isn’t everything, but it is something! Let’s see how Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose compare to Noom in this regard:
- Four Sigmatic: $20 for 16 servings, or $40 for 32 servings ($1.33/serving)
- Everyday Dose: Typically $52 for 30 servings ($1.20/serving)
- Noom: $35 for 30 servings ($1.16/serving)
All three brands let you save by buying larger quantities or subscribing to regular reorders. But the key takeaway here is Noom costs less and delivers more. You get double the functional content at roughly the same price, or potentially even lower. What more could you ask for?
Final Words on Four Sigmatic vs Everyday Dose
Whether you're drawn to the simplicity of Four Sigmatic’s traditional brew or intrigued by the smoother, low-caffeine blend from Everyday Dose, the best choice comes down to how you want to feel after your morning cup.
But with Noom offering stronger functional content per serving and a more well-rounded formula at a lower price, it’s hard to even consider alternatives. Our brew is the smarter upgrade you’ve been craving for your daily ritual.
You can see similar comparisons of Everyday Dose vs RYZE, Everyday Dose vs Beyond Brew, or Four Sigmatic vs Laird in our blog if you’re interested. But in comparing all the different options on the market to Noom, the end result is more or less the same.
Start sipping toward sharper mornings or more meaningful afternoons with Noom today!