It’s time for an honest conversation about your morning cup of coffee. It’s just not serving you the way you deserve anymore. Whether it’s the jitters and the crash or just the desire for more, there are smarter alternatives out there - like Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR.
These are two really popular functional beverages people turn to when they’re ready to upgrade their morning or afternoon cup. But as you’ll learn in this Mud WTR vs Beyond Brew comparison, they’re totally different.
Beyond Brew brings you organic cacao, probiotics, and a powerful blend of mushrooms: Lion's Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps (sinensis and militaris), and Turkey Tail.
Mud WTR has some of the same ingredients, like Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, and Cordyceps. But the base is Chai (or Matcha, depending on the formula you go with), and you also get turmeric, cinnamon, and other ingredients for functional support.
While each brings something special to the table, we think it’s worth noting that you get somewhere between 2,000mg to 2,240mg of functional ingredients per serving with Mud WTR or Beyond Brew. Our nootropic coffee gives you more than double that with 5,000mg.
Noom is designed for people who want more support than anything else on the market can provide. You get all the same mushrooms (and even a few extras), with 750mg of nootropics in every serving as well. See for yourself why it’s the best Beyond Brew and Mud WTR alternative!
“Glad to see the contents exceed the competition in active ingredients.” - Susan
“It was great, reordering now!” - Christine
“Love the product, and the soft cocoa taste!!! And I've tried many!!!” - Michael
Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR (Fast Facts)
|
Factor |
Noom |
Beyond Brew |
Mud WTR |
|
Mushroom Variety |
6 (Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps, Shiitake, Turkey Tail) |
5 (Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps, Turkey Tail) |
4 (Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps) |
|
Mushroom Content |
5,000mg |
~2,000mg |
~2,240mg |
|
Other Key Ingredients |
750mg nootropic stack (Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, NALT, Rhodiola, Guarana, Taurine) + collagen + cocoa, cinnamon, cardamom, and more |
Cacao + 3g fiber (acacia gum) + Bacillus coagulans probiotic |
Cacao + masala chai spices (turmeric, ginger, cinnamon, cardamom, etc.) + Himalayan salt |
|
Caffeine |
~56mg (from guarana) |
Very low (~1/20 cup coffee) |
~35mg (from black tea & cacao) |
|
Flavor & Texture |
Cocoa-based, smooth, slightly thicker; mixes cleanly |
Cocoa-forward, light; some find it thin without milk |
Spiced cacao/chai; warming but can be gritty if not whisked |
|
Price per Serving |
$1.33 - but double the functional content compared to Beyond Brew and Mud WTR |
$1.00 |
$1.33 |
|
Best For |
Maximum support for body and mind, better value for the money |
Gentle gut health support with almost no caffeine |
Flavorful ritual with mild caffeine and spice-forward taste |
Overview of Noom
Noom isn’t coffee dressed up with a few mushrooms. It’s a complete overhaul for your morning ritual. Instead of relying on roasted beans and all the acidity, jitters, and crashes that come with them, we use a cocoa base with a powerful stack of thoughtfully selected ingredients.
The Core Formula at a Glance
Each serving of Noom delivers 5,000mg of functional mushrooms, which is by far the highest dose you’ll find of any comparable product on the market. In fact, it’s more than double what you get with Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR! Here’s what’s included:
- Lion’s Mane: linked to focus and memory
- Cordyceps: supports endurance and natural energy
- Reishi: often used for relaxation and stress balance
- Chaga: packed with antioxidants for immune health
- Shiitake: tied to gut and cardiovascular support
- Turkey Tail: studied for immune resilience
On top of that mushroom backbone, Noom adds a 750mg nootropic stack featuring Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, Rhodiola Rosea, Guarana extract, and Taurine. Each of these has been chosen for a very specific reason, but they all share the common goal of helping you feel and perform better in your day to day life.
Supporting players like collagen peptides, cocoa, cinnamon, and cardamom round out the formula, giving each cup a rich, smooth flavor with a slightly thicker texture than black coffee.
Why Noom is the #1 Mushroom Coffee
A look at the label alone is enough for you to see what separates Noom from Mud WTR vs Beyond Brew, and other similar blends, for that matter. You get way more functional content in every serving.
But, it also tastes better for those who don’t love the traditional coffee flavor. It’s like a warm, comforting hot cocoa. You never find any sediment at the bottom of your mug. It mixes evenly and easily, a perfect choice for those hectic mornings.
Customers keep coming back they feel they’re getting incredible value for the money, too. Noom isn’t the cheapest beverage on paper, but it’s by far the smartest when you look at cost per milligram of ingredients.
We get it, though, if you want to take a closer look at how our blend compares to the other brand names you might be more familiar with. Let’s look at Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR below.
Overview of Beyond Brew
Beyond Brew is a coffee alternative that’s lighter on caffeine and heavier on gut and immune support. It still works really well to kickstart your mornings (or power through afternoons) with energy and focus, though.
What’s Inside Beyond Brew?
Each serving of Beyond Brew includes a 6-in-1 mushroom blend alongside prebiotics, probiotics, and cacao. The lineup balances cognitive support, immune defense, and digestion. The full list looks like this:
- Lion’s Mane: linked to focus and cognitive clarity
- Reishi: often used for stress management and relaxation
- Chaga: known for its antioxidant content and gut health potential
- Cordyceps (sinensis + militaris): tied to physical energy and stamina
- Turkey Tail: widely studied for immune resilience
- Cacao: delivers flavonols and a rich flavor base
- Acacia gum (dietary fiber): a prebiotic source to nourish healthy gut bacteria
- Bacillus coagulans: a hardy probiotic strain designed to survive digestion
You get roughly 3 grams of dietary fiber per serving, no sugar, and only 20 calories. Caffeine content is almost negligible at just 1/20th of a cup of coffee - that can be a good or bad thing depending on how you feel about stimulants.
You have no shortage of options, either. Flavors are offered in Original Cacao, Caramel Macchiato, and Vanilla Latte, all with the same functional core.
What Customers Do and Don’t Love About it
Beyond Brew is really gentle on the stomach, which is where a lot of functional drinks miss the mark. This can be traced back to the fiber and probiotics in the blend. The low caffeine level makes it accessible for people who are caffeine-sensitive or already cutting back, too.
The flavor is more like cocoa than coffee, which helps with drinkability, though some find it a bit thin without milk or cream. It’s a worthy choice if you’re looking for an easy replacement for an afternoon pick-me-up without risking a sleepless night.
So what’s the catch? Potency. At only a couple of grams of mushrooms per serving, Beyond Brew doesn’t come close to delivering the same concentration as stronger blends like Noom. There are no added nootropics or adaptogens, either.
You can learn more about Beyond Brew vs Everyday Dose or RYZE vs Beyond Brew in our blog if you’d like. But let’s turn our attention to the other half of our Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR comparison for now.
Overview of Mud WTR
Mud WTR has built its identity around being the ritualistic alternative to coffee, marketed with a bold, edgy personality. You’ve probably heard about it on social media - the ads when the brand first launched were impossible to escape.
This is definitely a unique alternative to coffee. Mud WTR leans into a spiced cacao-chai profile that’s more about the experience than the stimulation. Let’s look at what’s inside.
A Look at the Ingredients List
Mud WTR’s Original blend is built on cacao and masala-inspired spices, layered with functional mushrooms. Here’s the ingredient snapshot per serving:
- Mushrooms (~2,240 mg total): Chaga, Reishi, Lion’s Mane, Cordyceps (fruiting body & mycelium, cultured on organic oats/sorghum)
- Organic cacao: rich in antioxidants and the base flavor of the drink
- Spice blend: cinnamon, turmeric, ginger, cardamom, nutmeg, cloves, black pepper. It’s warming, anti-inflammatory, and aromatic
- Organic black tea powder: provides mild caffeine lift
- Himalayan pink salt: trace minerals and balance
Every serving provides about 20 calories, 0.5g fat, 4g carbs, and 1g fiber. Caffeine sits around 35mg per serving - closer to a cup of black tea than coffee. There are other options like the Matcha and Turmeric blends, and the company even introduced a Rest formulation recently.
Benefits and Drawbacks of Mud WTR
More than a million people have tried Mud WTR, so obviously, this blend does something right. It gives you a functional lift to get through the day with no jitters or crash.
The taste is really contentious, though. People tend to either love it or hate it. We’ve seen it referred to as warm and rich, which comes from spices and cacao. It seems to pair well with milk alternatives for a creamy finish. It feels more like preparing a chai latte or hot cocoa than mixing a supplement, which makes the experience enjoyable.
On the other hand, a lot of people say the name is very fitting. It can be a bit difficult to get down if you’re not a fan of chai or matcha. Customers say the preparation process is a little more involved than instant mixes, and some users describe a gritty texture if it isn’t whisked or blended properly.
But in looking at functional content per serving, you’re getting less than half what you would in Noom! It can feel like you’re settling once you realize what else is on the market.
Take a closer look at Mud WTR vs RYZE or Everyday Dose vs Mud WTR in our blog if you want - or learn more about Mud WTR vs Beyond Brew specifically below!
Mud WTR vs Beyond Brew vs Noom: Which Blend is Best?
For what it’s worth, all three of these brands have the same goal on the surface - deliver something that coffee alone never could. They each lean on functional mushrooms, cut the caffeine, and try to create a ritual you’ll actually look forward to.
That’s where the similarities end, and the difference between Mud WTR vs Beyond Brew and Noom becomes crystal clear. From mushroom dosage to extra ingredients, flavor experience, and value per serving, Noom stands apart from Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR.
Mushroom Variety and Potency
Mushrooms are the backbone of each blend, but how much you get and in what form changes the experience. Here’s a quick look at each blend:
- Beyond Brew (6 mushrooms): Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps (both sinensis and militaris), and Turkey Tail.
- Mud WTR (4 mushrooms): Lion’s Mane, Chaga, Cordyceps, and Reishi.
- Noom (6 mushrooms): Lion’s Mane, Reishi, Chaga, Cordyceps, Shiitake, and Turkey Tail.
What about potency, though? Mud WTR is one of the strongest on the market at 2,240mg of functional content per serving. While Beyond Brew doesn’t actually publish this information, third-party reviews claim it's somewhere around 2,000mg.
This is by far the biggest difference between Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR vs Noom. You get more than double the good stuff in each serving with Noom at 5,000mg of functional ingredients. The best part? It’s not just mushroom support.
Other Ingredients for Physical and Mental Support
Mushrooms are only one piece of the puzzle for all of these brands. They each go further, but one brand goes much further than the others.
Beyond Brew adds prebiotics, probiotics, and fiber. Each serving contains ~3 grams of dietary fiber plus Bacillus coagulans, a stable probiotic strain. This is why the blend is best known for gut support.
On the other hand, Mud WTR layers in cacao, spices, and black tea. The cacao adds flavonols and a chocolate backbone. The spice blend (turmeric, ginger, cinnamon, cardamom, and others) is more flavorful than functional, but these extras offer some anti-inflammatory support.
Noom is in a league of its own here. We’re the only brand that combines a comprehensive nootropic blend with the mushroom blend. You get Alpha-GPC, L-Theanine, N-Acetyl L-Tyrosine, Rhodiola Rosea, Guarana, and Taurine.
That’s 750mg of added ingredients to really help you feel and perform your best, whether it’s at work or in the classroom, in the gym, or just around the house. Beyond the nootropics, you also get collagen peptides, cocoa, cinnamon, and cardamom.
Noom is more than a mushroom beverage. It’s a complete brain-and-body performance drink.
The Caffeine Content
Caffeine is one of the biggest reasons people look to switch from coffee, but it’s not the enemy. It’s just too heavy in energy drinks or traditional java. That’s why the source and the amount of caffeine matters in comparing Noom with Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR.
Beyond Brew has almost no content, which can be a benefit or a limitation depending on your preferences. Every serving has 1/20th the amount of caffeine in the average cup of coffee. So, you won’t get that tangible lift you might want during the day.
Mud WTR gives you a bit more with 35mg of caffeine from black tea and cacao. That’s in line with a cup of green or white tea: light, but present enough to feel.
Still, though, we think it falls a little short of the sweet spot. That’s why our brew is dialed in with 56mg of caffeine per serving. It comes from guarana. This type of caffeine releases more slowly than coffee beans, so the energy lasts longer without a sharp spike or crash.
Flavor, Texture, and Preparation
Taste and convenience are deal breakers for something you plan to drink every day.
Mud WTR is definitely the most unique - for better or worse. Its chai-inspired flavor profile is loved and hated. Preparation can be fussier, too. You’ll need a whisk or frother to avoid clumps, and the texture can run gritty if you just stir with a spoon.
Beyond Brew and Noom are a bit more similar in that each has a warm, chocolatey flavor profile. We use cocoa; Beyond Brew uses cacao. The difference is in depth. Beyond Brew is lightly sweet. Noom tastes a bit more decadent and thicker thanks to the collagen content.
A lot of customers tell us Noom is more like a hot chocolate than a coffee replacement. You never have to worry about mixability or grit in the bottom of your mug, either.
Value for the Money
Pricing is close across the board - on paper, that is. It’s less about cost per serving, and more about value for the money. This is where the gap between Noom and Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR widens the most.
- Beyond Brew: about $1.00 per serving. Affordable, but lower mushroom content.
- Mud WTR: about $1.25 per serving. Mid-range price with a blend that’s heavier on flavor than potency.
- Noom: about $1.33 per serving. A touch more than Beyond Brew, but you’re getting more than double the functional mushrooms plus 750mg of nootropics.
When you look at cost per milligram of functional content, Noom clearly delivers the most value. It costs less than Mud WTR, slightly more than Beyond Brew, but gives you WAY more support in every scoop. It’s a no-brainer when you think about it this way!
Bringing Our Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR Comparison to a Close
Both brands have their strengths, but as we bring our Beyond Brew vs Mud WTR comparison to a close, it’s clear they’re very different. Beyond Brew leans into gut support with probiotics and fiber, while Mud WTR delivers a spice-forward ritual with modest caffeine
Compared to Noom, though, each of these blends falls short. Both in terms of formula sophistication and ingredient potency. With 5,000mg of mushrooms, a full 750mg nootropic stack, and a smooth cocoa base, Noom gives you more.
So why settle for less? Noom is the clear choice if you want a daily ritual that actually feels like an upgrade. Make the smarter swap with Noom now.